Clients often come to us with a familiar request: help me explain my experience so an employer will see my value.
Sometimes, that is exactly the problem, but sometimes, it isn’t.
Sometimes the resume is fine. The real issue is that the client is targeting work that is difficult to access, requires credentials they don't have, represents too large a leap from their current experience, or doesn't show enough demand to support the search.
Several recent workforce reports point toward a broader role for those of us who help people navigate career transitions.
Five or ten years ago, “find the transferable skills and tell the story better” was often a reasonable career-change strategy. Today, that is not enough. We have to establish a clear pathway between what the client has done and what they want to do.
Before we rewrite the resume, we should ask: Is there evidence that this destination is reachable?
McKinsey Global Institute's Workforce in Motion looks at career transitions through several lenses: demand for the destination occupation, overlap between the worker's current skills and the new role, the impact on wages, and the time required to obtain missing credentials.
Those are practical questions for us, too. Does the client already have enough relevant experience to make the move believable? If anything is missing, can the client close that gap through a course, certification, project, bridge role, or employer-based training? Would the client have to accept a major pay cut? Is the target occupation actually hiring in the client's market?
That doesn’t mean discouraging people from making career changes. It means being honest about what kind of transition they are attempting.
There is also an important distinction between transferable skills and readiness.
Opportunity@Work's research on the "paper ceiling” highlights the hidden capabilities professionals hide beneath job titles, degree requirements, or assumptions about lower-paid work.
Resume writers already know this. We uncover what people actually did. But "transferable" does not mean "automatically qualified." A retail supervisor may have experience with staffing, training, inventory, operations, and customer problem-solving. That can open doors beyond retail. But it doesn’t mean we should relabel the person as a project manager and hope the employer agrees.
Our job is to show the connection without overstating it.
One of the best questions we can ask is, “Tell me about a time when you actually did the kind of work this employer needs.” If the client cannot produce an example, we may be looking at a development problem, not a wording problem.
The same applies to professional branding. Instead of asking how to make the client sound more impressive, we can ask what evidence supports the claim.
"Strategic problem solver" is easy to write. But what problem did the person solve? What did they actually do? What judgment did they use? What changed because of it? Why would any of that matter to the next employer?
That creates a stronger resume, but it also creates a stronger career strategy.
Sometimes, the right next move isn't the ultimate destination. It may be a bridge role that provides relevant experience, a credential, access to internal opportunities, or exposure to a new function.
The underlying truth is that these days it’s not enough to ask, "Can we make this person sound ready?" We must ask, "What would actually make this person ready?" That is, we need to diagnose before we rewrite.
When a search isn’t working, the problem may be communication. It may be development. It may be access. Or it may be targeting.
A resume can help with the first one and clarify the others, but it can’t solve all four. Sometimes the most valuable thing we can do is recognize that before we start changing the words.
A fuller version of this article is available on the NRWA’s Business Resources Page, accessible to NRWA members as a membership benefit.